PM's Keep Failing This Interview: How to Ace Success Metrics

>50% of processes ask it. Here's how to ace it

After coaching PMs through job hunting for the past 5 years, one interview question consistently trips people up:

How would you measure the launch of GPT-5?

What are the success metrics you would use for an onboarding experiment?

This is a question that comes up in most PM interviews these days.

So every PM needs to master it.

---

What it Feels Like in Practice

One of my coaching candidates, Ashutosh, recently went through one.

They asked him to design success metrics for YouTube Shorts. He spent about 10 minutes building out a framework that would work well for most products.

That’s when the interviewer hit him with a curve ball:

That's all table stakes. What I want to know is: if you owned this product for two years, what metrics would tell you if you're building the future of YouTube or just another TikTok clone?

Luckily, he works with me and had a calm, structured approach to the curve ball. He thought aloud through 1. platform dynamics, 2. creator economics, and 3. long-term business model sustainability. Then he worked through the key metrics.

And he got the offer.

---

Today’s Post

I’m going to help you handle the curve balls of the success metrics interview, as well.

1. Overview of the Success Metrics Interview

   • Who Uses It

   • The Rubric They Use

   • The Common Frameworks

2. The Advanced Breakdown

   • My Framework

   • Real Example Answers

   • How to Handle Curveballs

3. My GPT to Help you Prepare + a Group to Practice Mocks with

I’ve already covered the product execution and product metrics interviews at the 101 level. This is the 201 deep dive on the success metrics question within them.

---

Before we go any further, I want to drop some concrete help. Here’s a complete mock interview I did with a former Meta and Google PM to show you the bar:

Now let’s get into the rest of the deep dive. (There’s never been such a deep dive on the web.)